Big Blue View mailbag: Dave Gettleman, Joe Judge, cross rush, extra

Can the New York Giants upset the Dallas Cowboys on Sunday? That’s a query that received’t be answered till Sunday night. We can, although, reply some Giants-related questions proper now. so, let’s open the Big Blue View Mailbag and do this.

David Bleecker asks: Let’s assume the Giants end the season with one thing near a .500 file. And let’s assume possession decides to maneuver on from Gettleman.

My understanding is Mara/Tisch rent the coach, not the GM. In your private opinion, do you assume they’d make retaining Judge a part of the package deal deal for the subsequent GM? Or do you assume it’s extra possible that they permit the subsequent GM to make their very own resolution concerning the pinnacle coach?

Ed says: David, I’ve mentioned this earlier than — I don’t assume Joe Judge goes anyplace. Whether Dave Gettleman would be the GM subsequent season or not is a reputable query. I feel there’s little or no probability somebody aside from Joe Judge is teaching the Giants subsequent season, no matter what occurs with the GM.

Giants followers want to just accept the concept nowadays it’s Judge’s imaginative and prescient driving this franchise. That doesn’t imply he has closing say on each resolution. It simply means Judge’s imaginative and prescient is the driving pressure behind the choices that get made.

Ben McAdoo lasted lower than two full seasons as head coach. Pat Shurmur lasted two seasons. John Mara mentioned when Judge was employed that the group understood they couldn’t preserve recycling head coaches each two years, and that with Judge being a younger, first-time head coach they have been going to should train extra endurance. As onerous as which may be at occasions, that’s precisely what I anticipate them to do.

Robert Forgione asks: Ed, with the shortage of a cross rush this 12 months, is it time to assume Lorenzo Carter and Oshane Ximines should not the solutions? I at all times preferred Carter, however he appears to not have that further gear to get to the QB on a constant foundation. Time for Quincy Roche, maybe. Also, it appears Graham is just not sending his safeties as a lot as final 12 months, true?

Ed says: Robert, the Giants have waited … and waited … and waited for Lorenzo Carter to show his extraordinary bodily presents into manufacturing. It simply hasn’t occurred. At this level, I feel Carter has in all probability proven us what he’s. That’s a helpful, however not dynamic, participant. Ximines flashed some cross rush potential as a rookie in 2019, however we’re not seeing it now. If he can’t be a pressure as a cross rusher, there’s no spot for him for my part.

As for blitzing, you may be shocked to know that Pro Football-Reference has the Giants blitzing 29.7 p.c of the time up to now this season. Only eight groups have blitzed extra typically.

Unfortunately, the Giants haven’t been productive. They are twentieth in sacks with 6, twenty ninth in stress share (19.4), thirtieth in quarterback knockdown share (5.6), and 14th in hurry share (10.3).

ESPN has the Giants as thirty first in cross rush win fee.

The plain fact of these numbers is that this — regardless of what number of gamers Patrick Graham is sending, these rushers should not successful their matchups typically sufficient. I don’t know if Quincy Roche might help, but when the Giants assume he can I’ve no subject with him taking part in extra and Ximines taking part in much less.

Don Bucc asks: We’ve debated at size concerning DG’s resolution to draft Saquon with the #2 choose with these opposing the choice arguing {that a} operating again ought to by no means be taken that top and positional worth issues. While I agree with that in primary idea and hoped for a commerce down that 12 months, I shortly embraced the choose and was nothing however thrilled after we obtained to expertise Saquon’s rookie 12 months. He appeared nothing lower than a prime 5 (arguably prime 1 or 2) offensive menace in your entire NFL. While he has clearly suffered the accidents since (not essentially as a result of he’s a RB), my query is admittedly this – is it not well worth the #2 choose in the event you consider you’re getting a prime 5 offensive menace in your entire NFL? Hindsight is in fact 20/20 and Saquon’s accidents are trigger for concern however this Sunday reminded us of how an successfully used Saquon can influence a recreation. Personally, I blame our coaches for principally utilizing him as an RB (which isn’t value a prime 2 choose) vs. the offensive menace he’s able to being. Thoughts?

Ed says: Don, you’re proper that that is hardly new territory. I really like Barkley as a participant and assume he’s a terrific consultant of the Giants franchise. He is able to issues that few gamers can do, and that perhaps few gamers have ever completed.

I’ve vacillated over time about whether or not the Barkley choose, which works towards my basic draft philosophy of not taking operating backs that extremely, was the appropriate one. The Giants had three selections in that draft:

  1. Take a quarterback. Probably Sam Darnold, perhaps Josh Allen.
  2. Trade down and take both Quenton Nelson or Bradley Chubb, and add a bunch of different picks.
  3. Take Barkley.

If they didn’t need the quarterback, I nonetheless consider the commerce down would have been the preferable possibility. I feel it will have accelerated the rebuilding course of and been the higher long-term play.

I feel Barkley would have been a implausible piece so as to add to a workforce that was able to win. It’s simply actually, actually onerous to begin a rebuild with a operating again — even one nearly as good as Barkley.

Now, the opposite a part of your query. Is it actually truthful to criticize the best way this teaching employees has used Barkley? I feel not. Joe Judge and Jason Garrett had him for lower than two video games final season. This season, they’ve had a Barkley who has been discovering his approach after final season’s main damage. To be trustworthy, they’re additionally nonetheless determining each what he runs greatest and what they’ll block with their ever-changing line.

Pat Shurmur used Barkley to the tune of 91 receptions in 2018. I liked the best way Garrett used Barkley vs. New Orleans — splitting him broad, getting him downfield, dumping him some well-time screens, handing him the ball on some RPOs the place he hit the road with a full head of steam. I’m excited to see if that continues. As you mentioned, Barkley — like Alvin Kamara and Christian McCaffrey — isn’t just a operating again.

Christopher White asks: When are Elerson Smith and Aaron Robinson resulting from be activated? Having confirmed properly on the Senior Bowl, I recall the Giants thought sufficient about them to not danger waiving them or inserting them on injured reserve. If wholesome sufficient, they may present helpful depth items. Are they progressing, and do the Giants foresee their taking significant snaps this 12 months, if just for the NFL expertise?

Ed says: Christopher the reply is totally different for every participant. Let’s undergo it.

Smith is on injured reserve with what has been known as a hamstring damage that he apparently suffered in rookie exercises the week previous to the official begin of coaching camp. He is at present eligible to be taken off IR, however that doesn’t imply it’s going to occur quickly.

It is my understanding that Smith went by a exercise early this week in entrance of Giants coaches and trainers. It would appear that after that exercise the Giants decided that he isn’t fairly prepared but. Once he’s prepared, the Giants will designate him for return from IR. Maybe that might be subsequent week. Once they designate him to return, the Giants have 21 days to determine whether or not to activate him or go away him on IR for your entire season. So, we’re in all probability midseason or later earlier than we see Smith in motion.

Robinson is on the Physically Unable to Perform (PUP) listing. He is just not eligible to return to motion till after Week 6. After that sixth week, which might be following the Giants recreation towards the Los Angeles Rams, the Giants have a five-week window wherein to permit Robinson to return to follow, place him on IR or waive him. Once Robinson does return to follow, the Giants would have three weeks to determine to position him on the 53-man roster or on season-ending IR.

Bruce Frazer asks: How lengthy do you assume it would take earlier than the Giants know if Isaiah Wilson is a worthy reclamation challenge and has the talents to take a spot on the O- line. If he is ready to overcome his points the Giants may need snagged a 1st spherical expertise in a a lot wanted place.

Ed says: Bruce, it’s going to take some time. Offensive line coach Rob Sale mentioned throughout the week that proper now the work with Wilson is to get him into situation. The man actually hasn’t performed soccer in an extended whereas now.

Here is what Sale mentioned:

“We’re trying to get him in shape and get him to where he can do more out on the field. That’s where we’re at right now. Get him in shape, get him caught up to speed so then we can really get a good evaluation on him.”

My guess is you received’t see Wilson on the 53-man roster anytime quickly. Maybe in no way this season.

Source link

Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Most Popular

To Top